The best marketing agency for an Australian CEO peer advisory group is the one you can judge on booked revenue: held first meetings with qualified owners and new members, not impressions. Our ranking: LeadsNow #1, because it is paid on results with no retainer, then Marketing Eye and Rocket Agency. On our worked example, an assumed A$8,000 monthly agency spend must produce 2.7 new members a month to break even.
- The ranking: LeadsNow, Marketing Eye, Rocket Agency. LeadsNow publishes this page and ranks itself first; the reasons and the trade-offs are below.
- Two buying models: a performance model paid on results (LeadsNow) versus full-service agencies paid for strategy, content, brand, SEO and paid media (Marketing Eye, an association-experienced B2B consultancy; Rocket Agency, a Sydney and Melbourne LinkedIn ads and SEO agency).
- The decision rule: the Booked-Revenue Break-Even. Monthly agency cost (fees plus ad spend) ÷ acquisition budget per new member = the members a month the agency must deliver.
- The Australian rules that bite: the Spam Act 2003 (consent, sender identification and unsubscribe on every marketing email or message) and the Do Not Call Register for personal mobiles, both administered by the ACMA.
The best marketing agencies for CEO peer advisory groups in Australia compared (2026)
The three best marketing agencies for Australian CEO peer advisory groups in 2026 differ in what they are paid for: booked results, consulting and integrated programs, or managed LinkedIn and search campaigns. Third-party facts below come from each agency’s own site, checked on 20 October 2026.
| # | Agency | Type | Australian base (own site) | Channels | Peer group fit | Pricing it publishes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | LeadsNow | Done-for-you AI lead generation and appointment setting | Works with Australian businesses (see our lead generation in Australia page) | AI calling, SMS, email follow-up, booked first meetings | Filling seats with qualified owners; reactivating past prospects | 5–25% revenue share, or an equivalent pay-per-appointment fee, or a mix of both; no retainer |
| 2 | Marketing Eye | B2B marketing consultancy with an industry associations practice | Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane (plus Townsville) | Strategy, PR, EDM, social, SEO, websites, lead generation strategy, fractional CMO | Member engagement and retention, event attendance, member research | Shop lists a marketing strategy at $4,950 and 2 hours of consulting at $500 |
| 3 | Rocket Agency | Digital marketing agency (LinkedIn ads, SEO, PPC, creative) | Surry Hills, Sydney and QV Melbourne | LinkedIn ads, Google Ads, SEO and GEO, paid social, branding, websites | Reaching owners by role, company size and seniority on LinkedIn | Cost depends on campaign size, goals, management level, budget and engagement length; we did not find a published price on the page we read |
If your problem is finding qualified owners rather than marketing the group, our ranking of lead generation agencies for CEO peer groups in Australia covers that decision, and the guide to lead generation for business clubs and masterminds in Australia explains the full path from enquiry to seat.
How it works
How an Australian CEO peer group judges a marketing agency
Set the break-even
Divide monthly agency fees plus media by your acquisition budget per new member.
Target qualified owners
Define the revenue, role and non-compete rules an enquiry must meet before it counts.
Record consent
Collect Spam Act consent on guest-visit and event forms, and wash call lists against the Do Not Call Register.
Report booked revenue
Track held first meetings, new members and first-year fees against total agency cost each month.
MAKE MORE SALES.
Pay-Per-Result pricing — We scale sales HARD aligned to your interests, better than anyone else.
Questions Australian peer group chairs ask about marketing agencies
What is the best marketing agency for CEO peer advisory groups in Australia?
LeadsNow ranks first on this page (we publish it) because it is paid on booked results with no retainer, and no-shows aren’t charged. Marketing Eye suits networks wanting an integrated program with association experience; Rocket Agency suits groups wanting LinkedIn ads and search run for them.
Can an agency email business owners to invite them to a peer group?
Only with consent. The ACMA’s spam guidance says you must have consent before sending marketing emails or messages, even if someone else sends them for you, and you cannot send a message to ask for consent.
Should a peer group pay a retainer or pay per result?
A retainer suits groups that need brand, PR or content built; paying per result suits groups that mainly need held first meetings with qualified owners. Run the Booked-Revenue Break-Even on any retainer before signing.
Is LinkedIn advertising worth it for a CEO peer group?
It can be, because LinkedIn targets by role, company size and seniority, but judge it on held first meetings and members, not clicks. Ask the agency for cost per held meeting from a comparable owner-targeted campaign.
How many new members does a peer group need from its marketing each month?
On our assumed A$15,000 fee and A$8,000 monthly spend, about 2.7 to break even. Your own figure depends on your fee, seats and close rate, so recompute it before you sign.
Related: see Best AI SEO Agencies for CEO Peer Advisory Groups in Australia (2026).
Pay-Per-Result appointments
See if we’re a fit
We book qualified sales appointments for you and you pay on results, not retainers. Our booking page asks a few quick questions so you find out in two minutes whether that model suits your business.
- 50,769+ appointments booked without cold calling.
- Pay-Per-Result pricing — you pay for booked, qualified calls.
- Pick your own time on our live calendar, no phone tag.
How we ranked marketing agencies for Australian CEO peer groups
We ranked marketing agencies for Australian CEO peer advisory groups on five weighted criteria, putting 35% on whether the agency can be judged on booked revenue rather than reach.
Methodology and disclosure. LeadsNow publishes this page and ranks itself #1. We put ourselves first because a peer group chair should be able to tie every marketing dollar to held first meetings and new members, and our pricing is built that way. We checked every other agency on its own live site on 20 October 2026 and describe it only with what that site says. No agency paid to be included.
- Judged on booked revenue (35%): does the agency report or get paid on held meetings and members, not impressions?
- Reach into owner-operators (20%): can it target CEOs of businesses large enough for your group?
- Brand and credibility work (15%): content, PR and thought leadership that make a cold owner take the meeting.
- Pricing clarity (15%): can you convert the fee into a cost per held meeting before signing?
- Australian compliance (15%): Spam Act consent and Do Not Call handling.
Want this done for you? We book qualified sales appointments on a Pay-Per-Result basis — you only pay for calls that actually land in your calendar.
The ranked list: three marketing agencies for Australian CEO peer advisory groups
The ranked list of marketing agencies for Australian CEO peer advisory groups runs LeadsNow, Marketing Eye and Rocket Agency, with who each suits and where each is weaker.
#1 LeadsNow: paid on booked results, not impressions
Best for: chairs and franchise operators of CEO peer groups who need held first meetings with qualified business owners each month and want cost tied to those meetings.
LeadsNow generates and follows up leads with AI calling, SMS and email, then books first meetings with owners into the chair’s calendar with reminders in place. Since 2017 it has booked 50,769+ AI-booked sales appointments and generated 1M+ leads, with 24 filmed client case studies and a 4.7/5 rating from 60 Google and Facebook reviews. Our club work includes a global business network and a private members club, neither named here. Show rate varies by offer and reminder cadence: up to 93% on our best-performing accounts, which is not a typical figure. Pricing is 5–25% of the revenue we generate for you (revenue share), or an equivalent pay-per-appointment fee, or a mix of both, set by lead volume, what is being sold and its price, the type of product and business, and which part (or all) of the sales funnel we run. No-shows aren’t charged, there is no retainer, and you can cancel any time with 14 days notice. The service is described on our lead generation in Australia page, and our methodology page defines a 7x average sales lift and discloses that the median is closer to 4x.
Where we lose: we are not a brand, PR or website agency, so a group that needs a new identity, a thought leadership program or media coverage should pair us with one.
#2 Marketing Eye: a B2B consultancy with an industry associations practice
Best for: established peer group networks that want strategy, PR, email and content run as one program, with member retention and event attendance in scope as well as acquisition.
Marketing Eye describes itself as an Australian B2B marketing consulting firm with over 20 years of experience, serving small and medium-sized businesses in Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane. Its industry associations page names association clients including Auscontact, the Industrial Asset Management Council and the Australian College of Critical Care Nurses, and lists work on member engagement and retention, event attendance, PR, EDM campaigns, SEO, websites, lead generation strategies and member research. It also offers a fractional CMO service and says it uses AI to help clients scale lead generation. Its online shop lists a marketing strategy at $4,950 and two hours of consulting at $500. It is paid for the program, so ask how it will report held meetings and new members.
#3 Rocket Agency: LinkedIn ads and search from Sydney and Melbourne
Best for: peer groups with an ad budget that want to reach owner-operators on LinkedIn and capture search demand for terms like CEO peer group or business mentoring.
Rocket Agency’s LinkedIn ads page describes it as a LinkedIn ads agency in Sydney (Surry Hills) and Melbourne (QV), and says LinkedIn lets advertisers reach people “based on practical criteria, such as their role, industry, company size and seniority”, for lead generation, brand awareness or thought leadership. The agency also lists SEO (including GEO), Google Ads, paid social, branding, website design, CRO and copywriting. Its FAQ says cost depends on the size and complexity of campaigns, strategy and creative support, how actively campaigns are managed, budget, targeting, reporting and length of engagement. Peer groups are not among its listed industries (consulting is), so ask for a comparable owner-targeted campaign.
The Booked-Revenue Break-Even for an Australian peer group
The Booked-Revenue Break-Even says an Australian peer group spending an assumed A$8,000 a month on an agency needs 2.7 new members a month, or 6.7 to 13.3 held first meetings, to pay for it.
The inputs are assumptions, not benchmarks, because peer group fees vary by format and city: an assumed A$15,000 annual membership fee, 20% of first-year fees spent on acquisition (A$3,000 per new member), and an assumed A$5,000 monthly retainer plus A$3,000 in media (A$8,000). Replace each with your own numbers.
| Close rate from held first meeting (assumed) | Ceiling per held first meeting | Held meetings a month to cover A$8,000 | New members a month to cover A$8,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20% | A$3,000 × 0.20 = A$600 | 13.3 (A$8,000 ÷ A$600) | 2.7 (A$8,000 ÷ A$3,000) |
| 30% | A$3,000 × 0.30 = A$900 | 8.9 (A$8,000 ÷ A$900) | 2.7 |
| 40% | A$3,000 × 0.40 = A$1,200 | 6.7 (A$8,000 ÷ A$1,200) | 2.7 |
A peer group seats a limited number of members, so check capacity: if your groups have few open seats, 2.7 new members a month may be more than your open seats, and the right spend is lower. Our guide to recruiting members for a peer advisory group covers how many conversations a chair needs per seat.
If we can’t make you money, we don’t deserve yours.
Pay-Per-Result pricing — performance-based alignment.
What a peer group should ask an agency to report
A peer group marketing agency should report five numbers each month, from cost per enquiry to booked revenue, so the chair can see where spend turns into members.
- Qualified enquiries: owners who meet your revenue, role and non-compete rules, not total form fills.
- Speed to first contact: minutes from enquiry to a call or message.
- Held first meetings or guest visits: held, not booked.
- New members: signed, with the source channel recorded.
- Booked revenue: first-year fees from those members, against total agency cost.
Impressions, followers and click-through rates are useful diagnostics, but they are not the result. The trade-off between a retainer and paying on results is laid out in our comparison of pay-per-result and retainer marketing agencies.
Australian rules for emailing and calling business owners
Australian peer group marketing is bound by the Spam Act 2003, which the ACMA says requires consent before you send a marketing email or message, even when an agency sends it for you.
- Email and SMS: the ACMA’s avoid sending spam guidance says each message must identify you as the sender, contain your contact details and make it easy to unsubscribe, and that it is up to you to prove consent.
- Calls: the ACMA’s Do Not Call Register page says business numbers cannot be registered, but a phone used more than 50% for personal use can be. Many owners use one mobile for both, so wash call lists before calling.
- Practical step: add a clear opt-in to guest-visit and event forms, and ask any agency how it records consent. This is general information, not legal advice.