Let's grow your business. 2 new positions just opened Saturday, 10 October. Book a free call today.
Uncategorised 7 min read

How To Re-Engage Old Fitness Client Leads

How To Re-Engage Old Fitness Client Leads: Email, SMS and voice outreach from an AI sales agent converging into a booked calendar appointment.
Email, SMS and voice outreach from an AI sales agent converging into a booked calendar appointment.

Tips On Attaining Your Old Fitness Client’s

Have you got a long list of leads that you have been unsuccessful in getting across the line to join your gym (or take up your PT services)? When was the last time you spoke to these old leads?

 

For many Gyms, PT’s and Fitness Centers…the answer to that question will be nothing. Just because a lead has turned cold, that doesn’t mean we should move on and forget about them. Old leads can still be brought back into the sales funnel and nurtured once again with the hope of having success in the future. Think about it. At the time you were unable to convert them into a paying membership perhaps that person was not in a financial position to join,  or perhaps they weren’t in the right mindset, or simply had too much going on in their life to finally make the commitment to better health & fitness. So here we are in the future and that lead may be crying out for some help to lose weight, get stronger, increase their confidence and energy…. and who should answer that cry for help but you! Their local Gym. 

How it works

Where lead generation actually leaks

01

Not enough qualified leads

Volume is the obvious problem, and usually the least important of the four.

02

Slow or missing follow-up

Most enquiries are contacted once. The buyer who needed a fourth touch is simply lost.

03

Weak qualification

Sales time is spent on people who were never going to buy, so the ones who would get less attention.

04

Nothing is ever re-worked

Quoted-but-not-closed opportunities go cold permanently instead of being revisited.

Very little revenue is lost at one dramatic point. It drains at four ordinary ones, and each is fixable independently.

MAKE MORE SALES.

Pay-Per-Result pricing — We scale sales HARD aligned to your interests, better than anyone else.

 

Your fitness business should have a nurturing strategy in place for these leads so that you can regularly provide them with both valuable information, and promotional information to get them to finally take action. 

Here’s some ideas for your old fitness lead nurture program.  

1.Automated Email (eDM)

Set up a pipeline of content that positions your fitness business as the experts in health and fitness. Exercise, Nutrition and General Wellbeing emails will help to build up your repute with an old lead, without pushing a special offer or a sales pitch down their throats. Your emails to their inbox will serve as a constant reminder that you are there, waiting and ready to help them. Whilst we recommend these emails shouldn’t be sales orientated, there’s no harm in including clear call to actions at the end of each piece. For example, if your email is about nutrition, a simple call to action at the end to alert them to your nutrition services will align nicely. 

 

Want this done for you? We book qualified sales appointments on a Pay-Per-Result basis — you only pay for calls that actually land in your calendar.

Intermittently you should add some promotional email sequences amongst the value-add content. For example, a 21-day sale, or a 28-day bootcamp offer, a 6-week challenge. Create one campaign per month to re-engage old leads and make sure it is something new each time. You should have a number of emails focused on this offer, so you are alerting the leads about the program, reminding them mid-way and then a final reminder as the offer is about to expire. Make sure you create urgency and really talk to the value your program is providing. Make it easy for leads to get in contact with you to secure the offer by providing links within the email to respond, call or SMS you, email you, or register via weblink. 

2. Automated SMS Blasts

Automated SMS blasts are great for older leads and it provides them with an opportunity to simply text or call you back to take advantage of an offer.

Here’s content that you can share via SMS:

  • Simple ‘check-in’ texts i.e. Hey John, quite some time ago you expressed interest in our gym. Just checking in to see how you have progressed with your health & fitness goals. If you are still needing some support, we would love to welcome you in on a free trial session, where we can chat more about how we can help. SMS me back if you are interested. Dave
  • Promotional deals – the same promotional deals you have set up to push via email can also be promoted through SMS. Set up 1 – 2 texts per campaign 
  • Proof of Results – Before/After shots or testimonials from your clients with a message such as ‘are you interested in getting results like these? We can help you. Message us back and let’s chat’
  • Announcements – new services, competitions, changes to the gym or events should be promoted to your old leads via SMS

gymautomatedsms

3.Phone Calls

Cold-calling isn’t for everyone, but it can work wonders. If you haven’t spoken too old leads for quite some time then it may be worth reaching out to them via a phone call. Be clear on your objective with your calls, and make sure you have an incentive ready. Try and get the lead into the gym for an appointment within 24-48hours to improve your chances of success.

You may wish to outsource this to a professional if you really want results and don’t feel comfortable doing this yourself. 

4.Messenger

Lots of leads these days come in via Facebook Messenger. If you have conversations that ended abruptly, or people had excuses that they weren’t ready then and there…it can be easy to send them another quick message to check-in and see whether they may now be in a position to take action. 

 

5.Snail Mail

Print is not dead! An old-fashioned mail out is quite unexpected in today’s digital world and so there may be an opportunity for you to wow your old fitness leads with something a big different. Two things are important here – the design and the incentive. Make your piece of mail stand out and make sure there is a strong incentive to get that lead back into the fold and keen to try your services again. Shock and awe is the way to go!

Don’t let old leads go to waste. There is still an opportunity re-engage them and remind them about your brand and the services you offer. Implement a nurture program that sees you touching base with them regularly. There will be those that opt-out and simply aren’t interested, but there will also be those leads that move further down the pipeline toward a sale. 

If we can’t make you money, we don’t deserve yours.

Pay-Per-Result pricing — performance-based alignment.

50,769+
AI-booked appointments
7×
Average sales lift
Pay-Per-Result
Performance-based alignment

 

Don’t forget old Gym or PT Members either. You should have a system in place for bringing them back in again too!

oldclientcalls

If you want a simple and intuitive system for engaging old leads, then look no further than even More Gym Members. This automated software system will send pre-built emails and SMS’s to your prospective clients to help increase your customer conversion rates. 

 

Pay-Per-Result appointments

See if we’re a fit

We book qualified sales appointments for you and you pay on results, not retainers. Our booking page asks a few quick questions so you find out in two minutes whether that model suits your business.

  • 50,769+ appointments booked without cold calling.
  • Pay-Per-Result pricing — you pay for booked, qualified calls.
  • Pick your own time on our live calendar, no phone tag.
View all articles

Pay-Per-Result · No retainers

Turn this into booked sales calls.

Our AI agents — trained on 50,769+ booked appointments — fill your calendar with pre-qualified buyers. You only pay when calls land.

Keep reading

Related on Leads Now AI

The thesis behind everything we do

Why Pay-Per-Result is the only marketing pricing model that aligns the agency with you

Leads Now AI is a 100% Pay-Per-Result marketing agency. You only pay when a qualified booked appointment lands on your calendar — priced as a revenue share of 5–25% of the sales we generate for you, a fee per appointment that shows up, or any mix of the two. Every option bills on outcomes. Not on clicks. Not on lead-form fills. Not on retainer months. Not on “strategy hours.” If the calendar stays empty, you owe zero. See full pricing →

1. Incentives align

The agency only succeeds when you succeed. We eat the cost of bad ad creative, bad lists, no-shows, and contacting the thousands of people who never book. You never pay for our learning curve.

2. Self-selecting shortlist

Only an agency confident in its delivery can operate this model. The pool of Pay-Per-Result agencies is tiny precisely because most agencies can’t survive on it. Pick from the agencies who can.

3. Cost cannot detach from revenue

Priced as a share of the revenue we generate, your acquisition cost stays sustainable across LTV bands. A $500-membership business and a $50,000-engagement business can both run the model profitably.

4. No retainer trap

The standard engagement carries no monthly retainer — nothing arrives on your invoice regardless of outcome. No 6 or 12-month lock-in, no clawback on appointments already delivered, cancel any time with 14 days notice. Early-stage businesses that need the sales systems built first are quoted scoped groundwork up front, never a standing fee.

5. De-risks the pilot

Test before commitment. A small scope-based setup fee covers hard build costs; everything after that is purely outcome-linked. There’s no “we’ll see how it performs after $30k of spend.”

6. Forces agency discipline

If our ads miss, if our reminders fail, if our no-show recovery doesn’t fire — we eat the cost. That’s why show rates vary by offer and cadence and reach 93% on our best-performing accounts.

The volume argument

A fully-ramped human SDR produces on the order of $200,000 a year. They work one conversation at a time, sleep, take leave, and cap out at a territory. Our agents work every lead in the list in parallel — responding in seconds, following up indefinitely without getting bored, and adding capacity without adding headcount.

At 100 qualified booked appointments a month against a $5,000 average deal value, that is $500,000 of booked pipeline every month — roughly what one SDR produces in two and a half years.

Read that precisely: booked pipeline means appointments multiplied by your average deal value. It is not closed revenue — closing is your side of the table, and your close rate decides what lands. The inputs above are a worked example; we size them to your actual deal economics before quoting. What we can evidence on our own numbers: 50,769+ appointments delivered since 2017, database reactivation converting 4.4–8.9% on dormant CRM lists, and show rates that vary by offer and reminder cadence — up to 93% on our best-performing accounts.

The proof: 50,769+ AI-booked sales appointments delivered since 2017 across coaches, consultants, RTOs, course creators, finance brokers and B2B service firms in Australia, USA, UK, Canada, NZ and Europe. Named clients include Sam Tajvidi (121 Brokers), Marcus Wilkinson (Iron Body), Foundr, SheSells.online and Lambda Academy. Wikidata Q139846230. See full Pay-Per-Result pricing →